AFF Doublethink Online » ALEC and NCSL: A Timely Comparison

ALEC and NCSL: A Timely Comparison

by Emily Sedgwick | August 5, 2002

Article Tools
Post a Comment
E-mail this Article
Printer-Friendly Version
More in Politics & Prose

Two thousand state legislators, business leaders, and think tank representatives convened in Orlando, Florida August 7-9 for the 29th American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) annual meeting. Two weeks prior, the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCLS) held its annual meeting in Denver, Colorado. The differences between the two conferences and host organizations are striking and indicative of the choices that face state governments during difficult economic times.

Both ALEC and NCSL offer model legislation, in-depth policy analysis, database resources, and the all-important annual meeting where politicos of many stripes can debate the topics of the year. This year, the main topic at both conferences was spending: on anti-terrorism, Medicaid, transportation, the environment, and the result of spending too much: budget deficits.

At NCSL, conference participants with the appropriate pass could attend three workshops on the Streamlined Sales Tax Project (SSTP), an attempt to “simplify” state tax codes to include Internet taxation and a uniform sales tax code. Two workshops addressed obesity and ways that states can spend more to curtail the problem. Another policy session examined the “tax pressure” on state revenue coffers apparently resulting from recent federal tax cuts as well as the revenue-boosting benefits of decoupling state death and income taxes from their federal cousins.

On July 25, an NCSL committee discussed the federal budget: “A process originally designed for deficit reduction was meaningless during a period of surpluses. Now that the deficits have returned, the rules are still ignored.” No mention was made of ballooning state deficits, except to blame them on the federal government. Later that afternoon, a committee examined the use of rainy day funds to balance state budgets (spending cuts were hardly mentioned). Another committee recommended gaming revenues as a means of “patching budget holes.”

Meanwhile, ALEC hosted a refreshing policy discussion section during NCSL at a hotel nearby. The topics for discussion were drawn from a recently published paper titled “Show Me the Money” that details spending and inefficiency reduction strategies. Recommendations like state hiring freezes and the elimination of phantom positions, across-the-board spending cuts, market-based and consumer-choice Medicaid reform, selling or leasing government assets and enterprises, and consolidating small agencies were just a few of the pro-taxpayer budget management solutions discussed by the panel and audience that morning. What a breath of fresh air.

Governor Bill Owens of Colorado spoke to a meeting of the National Republican Legislators Association, also concurrent to NCSL, about his state’s Taxpayers Bill of Rights, Colorado’s positive business and income climate, and his opposition to SSTP. More fresh air.

On just the first day of the ALEC annual meeting, various panels addressed the “regulation through litigation” problem in the courts, the “Crisis in State Spending,” “Cost-Effective Medicaid,” and the “New’ War on Drugs: the Pharmaceutical Debate.” Even the titles of these discussions indicate a more moderate approach to the issues of the day, and all conference attendees can attend — no “pass” required.

Furthermore, ALEC speakers are markedly more in touch with reality than NCSL’s speakers. ALEC hosted Secretaries Elaine Chao, Ron Paige, and Mel Martinez, U.S. Representative Mark Green (R-Wis.), and author Bjorn Lomborg. NCSL keynote speakers included Mike McCurry (who “served as White House press secretary during some of the most challenging times faced by the Clinton administration”) and John Sweeney, President of AFL-CIO, who made the serious mistake of attacking ALEC in his speech to an NSCL breakfast audience on July 25.

According to Sweeney, ALEC “positions itself as a non-partisan grassroots organization, but in reality it is a Washington-based group of corporations and wealthy right-wing reactionaries who are spending millions of dollars to usurp state legislatures.” Legislators and numerous others in attendance walked out in protest. NCSL executive director Bill Pound later called ALEC executive director Duane Parde to apologize for Sweeney’s comments.

Sweeney did bring up an interesting point about NCSL and ALEC’s respective membership, although he got the point wrong. Taxpayer dollars enable state delegations of legislators to attend NCSL meetings and to afford the cost of membership and online services. ALEC members, including 2,400 state legislators - 65% republican, 35% democratic - pay out-of-pocket to afford registration, hotel accommodations, and travel arrangements. This would indicate that ALEC is hardly a heavy-handed reactionary with millions to toss around.

Furthermore, not only are ALEC membership dues cheaper than NCSL’s, but ALEC membership costs taxpayers nothing. A one-year voluntary membership to ALEC costs an individual legislator $25. A one-year membership to NCSL, estimated using population and revenue data, costs the California legislature $900,000. Each legislature’s dues are different, but if there are 120 legislators (house and senate) in California, individual NCSL membership works out to be $7,500. If Governor Davis and his Democrat-controlled Legislature are serious about their budget shortfall, I’ve got a great recommendation for making a dent. ALEC is simply a better alternative to NCSL.

Thousands of state legislators attend NCSL and ALEC annual meetings every summer. They are the next generation of Governors, Congressmen, and Cabinet officials: Robert Kasten, Tommy Thompson, John Engler, Terry Branstad, and John Kasich are all ALEC alumni. The differences between NCSL and ALEC aren’t surprising, necessarily, but taxpayers bankrolling involvement in either organization should raise eyebrows. The next generation shouldn’t get too comfortable spending our tax dollars.

Share This Article:

Add 'ALEC and NCSL: A Timely Comparison' to Del.icio.us

Add 'ALEC and NCSL: A Timely Comparison' to digg

Add 'ALEC and NCSL: A Timely Comparison' to reddit

Add 'ALEC and NCSL: A Timely Comparison' to Technorati

Add 'ALEC and NCSL: A Timely Comparison' to Stumble Upon

Add 'ALEC and NCSL: A Timely Comparison' to Google Bookmarks

Add 'ALEC and NCSL: A Timely Comparison' to Bloglines

Add 'ALEC and NCSL: A Timely Comparison' to FaceBook

183 Comments - add your own

thermocarb — October 28, 2004 at 2:56 pm

Hello.

I’ve been looking around and came across your site by accident. The information you link to from your home page is quite informative so thanks for taking the time to post it.

Joe
thermocarb

paparulo — December 7, 2005 at 8:51 am

des sonnerie pour mobile , telecharger google fr..

chistas — December 9, 2005 at 2:41 pm

gratuit , amatrice gratuit site perso , video..

carvello — December 13, 2005 at 12:20 pm

libri gialli e thriller bompiani , recensione libro il nome della rosa

ana — December 14, 2005 at 12:23 pm

artiguero — December 15, 2005 at 2:33 pm

pamela anderson video honeymoon , pamela anderson

hot girl — December 16, 2005 at 9:53 am

visit the above website

kokus — December 19, 2005 at 2:30 pm

le gran site partners bonne cualite et etudiantes

catali.. — December 19, 2005 at 3:31 pm

oedipe, hotel mantes jolie , insertion et plus

nebera — December 20, 2005 at 2:21 pm

hentai blue girl

kamatruty — December 21, 2005 at 1:55 pm

cd rom instrument de musique , graver de la musique sur cd

grafollo — December 22, 2005 at 4:08 pm

classement des meilleur musique du moment

kebec — December 22, 2005 at 7:28 pm

Telechargement kazaa musique and humor !!!

Norte — December 22, 2005 at 8:52 pm

Telechargement logo entreprise

paxil vs_ zoloft — December 26, 2005 at 5:41 am

how paxil effects eeg paxil for depression http://rublik.otbet.ru/paxil/epilepsy_and_paxil.html paxil side effects paxil uses http://rublik.otbet.ru/paxil/hoarding_paxil.html and …. paxil stop taking quiting paxil http://rublik.otbet.ru/paxil/picture_of_paxil.html paxil cr 12_5 recall going off paxil http://rublik.otbet.ru/paxil/paxil_clomipramine.html between drug interaction ionamin paxil paxil withdrawl symptons http://rublik.otbet.ru/paxil/paxil_memory_loss_problem.html .Thanks.

aloisio — December 26, 2005 at 11:46 am

hard video gratuite , moteur trouver die et click

ragna — December 26, 2005 at 12:23 pm

hard gratuite , photo hard blakeuses russian hard

jony — December 29, 2005 at 6:28 am

magasin usine vetement diesel italie , grossiste vetement enfant paris

tio — December 29, 2005 at 7:52 am

Great site with great dispossition and material, thanks friends

Visco — December 29, 2005 at 4:52 pm

Gustafs — December 29, 2005 at 5:53 pm

Enter here to watch the most expectacular lesb. photos

adrian — December 30, 2005 at 2:50 pm

eveil et jeu ligne , flash game jeu voiture , inscription jeu tf1

balbin — December 30, 2005 at 3:30 pm

java nokia 6230 , jeu java lg , jeu reseau sans inscrire

scarles — January 2, 2006 at 8:41 am

nouveaux emoticone animee , comment telecharger emoticone

fearana — January 2, 2006 at 10:06 am

telecharger icone gratuit francais , fun club samsung

Marcus — January 2, 2006 at 9:07 pm

Lindolfo — January 3, 2006 at 1:05 pm

pencheto — January 5, 2006 at 7:35 am

photo et film porno gratuit , gratuit video porno gratiut

pertucherme — January 5, 2006 at 8:29 am

histoire porno sado maso , jeu flash porno , porno asiatique video

Eraclito — January 5, 2006 at 12:39 pm

Ecate — January 5, 2006 at 1:58 pm

Free video games, telecharger and game boy advance

online strip poker with real people — January 9, 2006 at 5:17 am

are online poker winnings taxable online poker cheating programs http://www.hallkidstales.com/poker/texas_holdem_online_poker.html online poker deposit visa online poker aide http://www.hallkidstales.com/poker/casino_casino_game_online_poker.html and …. where to play free online poker play poker online for money paypal http://www.hallkidstales.com/poker/free_online_strop_poker.html online poker real money bonuses online poker cheat software http://www.hallkidstales.com/poker/review_poker_online.html free online poker rooms free online strip poker http://www.hallkidstales.com/poker/poker_player_names_online.html .Thanks.

yeferson — January 9, 2006 at 8:33 am

sexe video amateur gratuit prive , telecharger video sexe gratos

mantecolenator — January 9, 2006 at 9:34 am

sexe amateur video gratuite

money online play poker — January 9, 2006 at 12:42 pm

online poker leagues online video poker casino http://www.hallkidstales.com/poker/online_poker_player.html online poker sites for sale copenhagen online poker http://www.hallkidstales.com/poker/free_online_poker_no_money_necessary.html and …. live online poker tournament best online strip poker http://www.hallkidstales.com/poker/online_poker_player.html cheat online poker money online play poker http://www.hallkidstales.com/poker/play_pai_gow_poker_online.html online poker bonus online poker free http://www.hallkidstales.com/poker/online_poker_cheating_programs.html .Thanks.

Herodoto — January 9, 2006 at 2:50 pm

Chancleto — January 9, 2006 at 4:27 pm

how to increase mobility in sperm — January 10, 2006 at 1:24 am

how to increase mobility in sperm how to increase sperm load http://www.hallkidstales.com/sperm/increase_sperm_count_herbs.html increase sperm count and motility how to increase sperm production http://www.hallkidstales.com/sperm/herbs_to_increase_sperm_production.html and …. how to increase sperm load by eating natural food how to increase sperm load by eating natural food http://www.hallkidstales.com/sperm/remedies_to_increase_sperm_count.html chlomid increase sperm count increase your sperm load http://www.hallkidstales.com/sperm/increase_sperm_ejaculation.html increase sperm load ways to increase sperm count http://www.hallkidstales.com/sperm/increase_sperm_-_ejactulation.html .Thanks.

Zoctopus — January 12, 2006 at 12:11 am

Chocustum — January 12, 2006 at 12:44 am

generic pill viagra — January 12, 2006 at 5:20 am

generic lowest price viagra generic viagra wholesale http://moroz.straponclub.com/generic_viagra/oklahoma_generic_viagra.html generic viagra woman generic money order viagra http://moroz.straponclub.com/generic_viagra/generic_viagra_omnigen.html and …. purchase generic viagra generic uk viagra http://moroz.straponclub.com/generic_viagra/viagra_cialis_generic.html cheap generic substitute viagra generic pill viagra http://moroz.straponclub.com/generic_viagra/generic_viagra_sildenafil.html generic inexpensive viagra canada generic viagra http://moroz.straponclub.com/generic_viagra/generic_viagra_pharmacy.html .Thanks.

lipitor negative side effects — January 15, 2006 at 4:49 am

yes.this is my site http://hochulexus.chbn.ru/lipitor/lipitor_functionality.html Thanks.

side effects of ultracet — January 15, 2006 at 7:07 am

mcneil tab ultracet ultracet tablet http://hochulexus.chbn.ru/ultracet/ultracet_faqs.html compare ultram ultracet and hydrocodone ultram or ultracet http://hochulexus.chbn.ru/ultracet/ultracet_tablet.html and …. ultracet _ dosage of ultracet http://hochulexus.chbn.ru/ultracet/stop_sciatic_pain_with_ultracet.html ultracet dosage mcneil tab ultracet http://hochulexus.chbn.ru/ultracet/ultracet_faq.html benadryl neurontin zocor ultracet thyroid ultracet tablets http://hochulexus.chbn.ru/ultracet/ultracet_tablets.html .Thanks.

zyban pill — January 17, 2006 at 1:23 am

testimonials of people using zyban zyban uk http://porevo.freemegavideo.com/zyban/zyban_side_effects.html taking zyban side effects to zyban http://porevo.freemegavideo.com/zyban/buy_zyban_canada.html and …. zyban wp zyban cheapest http://porevo.freemegavideo.com/zyban/zyban_does_it_work.html zyban smoking cessation zyban medication http://porevo.freemegavideo.com/zyban/zyban_side_affect.html working mechanism of zyban zyban recommended dosage http://porevo.freemegavideo.com/zyban/short_term_side_effect_of_zyban.html .Thanks.

super — January 17, 2006 at 6:48 am

and free http://sraka.myip.us/1/22.html or and http://sraka.myip.us/1/32.html and …. or yes http://sraka.myip.us/1/21.html and html http://sraka.myip.us/1/25.html free yes http://sraka.myip.us/1/45.html .Thanks.

Shotum — January 17, 2006 at 4:59 pm

Software , real estate and installation of webcam creative, software engraving cd proteger and more.

Empire — January 17, 2006 at 5:28 pm

C program spin executive, software diskeeper ÃÂ?ÃÂÃÂ¡how to evaluate diskeeper.htm !

cheap smokes cheap cigarettes — January 18, 2006 at 6:47 am

yes.this is my site http://gorlum-pidaras.hallwriting.com/cheap_cigarettes/buy_duty_free_cigarettes_online_cheap_marlboro____s.html Thanks.

weight loss and diet product links — January 18, 2006 at 3:58 pm

fda soy products for weight loss program weight loss product http://gorlum-pidaras.hallwriting.com/weight/top_healthy_weight_loss_products.html skinnee weight loss product healthy loss product weight http://gorlum-pidaras.hallwriting.com/weight/effective_loss_most_product_weight.html and …. weight loss product attorneys weight loss product attorneys http://gorlum-pidaras.hallwriting.com/weight/ephedra_loss_product_weight.html herbalife weight loss products reviews weight loss management products http://gorlum-pidaras.hallwriting.com/weight/ephedrine_weight_loss_product.html weight loss products w program weight loss product http://gorlum-pidaras.hallwriting.com/weight/alliance_loss_product_weight.html .Thanks.

Miracle — January 21, 2006 at 12:27 am

You want to know how your favorite group was formed

Misbela — January 21, 2006 at 12:39 am

Find out about the last innovations of the musical ambience

wine note — January 22, 2006 at 11:09 am

wine
beer wine liquor
wine rack
wine gift basket
wine club
wine gift
wine basket
wine cooler
food and wine
wine country gift basket
wine store
wine glasses
red wine
wine cellar
iron and wine
wine spectator
wine storage
wine online
wine making
wine of the month club
strawberry wine
wine enthusiast
book en in investing primeur wine
wine refrigerator
wine bar
wine accessory
wine country
wine tasting
wine of the month
red red wine
wine tour
wine cabinet
california wine
wine and spirits
french wine
buy wine online
wine opener
total wine
wine country basket
wine rating
napa wine
ice wine
wine shop
buy wine
wine chiller
port wine
italian wine
white wine
wine of the world
mulled wine
wine label
wine making kit
wine bottle
wine making supply
wine glass
california wine tour
wine review
wine note
german wine
fine wine
april wine
wine decanter
wine country gift
wine prices
type of wine
food world wine
oregon wine
australian wine
food and wine magazine
riedel wine glasses
wine stopper
mulled wine recipe
wine glass rack
iron and wine lyric
wine charm
wine and cheese
wine bottle opener
food and wine pairing
wrought iron wine rack
dessert wine
wine carrier
southern wine and spirits
sparkling wine
wine guide
sams wine
wine decanters
sweet wine
merlot wine
wine bottle holder
metal wine rack
monthly wine club
stemless wine glasses
how to make wine
napa wine tour
best wine
wine library
wine glass charm
wine merchant
http://www.azwinebottles.com
http://www.azwinebottles.com
http://www.azwinebottles.com

jessy — January 23, 2006 at 9:04 am

Great blog friends and keep working hard, i leave this site very cool..

lester — January 23, 2006 at 10:23 am

Oh tiny,,you are wonderful babie i love you!!

Ranoclates — January 24, 2006 at 7:29 pm

Tight buns of steel

Victimus — January 24, 2006 at 8:12 pm

Fellas don’t miss this one. Enjoy!!!!!

florenci — January 31, 2006 at 11:18 am

Zeus — January 31, 2006 at 4:22 pm

The best recipes for your delight !!!

Hera — January 31, 2006 at 5:27 pm

The best recipes that you could taste !!!

mirtha — February 1, 2006 at 8:45 am

AFF's Doublethink