First there was her assertion that Knocked Up features “nonexistence of abortion as an option,” which was, on its face, an absurd notion. Then this, on The Dark Knight:
In short, Chris Nolan does more nuanced thinking about the war on terror than we’ve seen from the Bush administration in seven years. And despite a falsely heroic closing speech from Gary Oldman’s character, police Lt. Jim Gordon, the movie seems to arrive at much the same conclusion about Batman as Americans have about Bush: Thanks to this guy, we’re well and thoroughly screwed.
Leaving aside the asinine, obligatory Bush-bashing (he’s a dunce! I’m so morally superior!), the last sentence is, simply, wrong. That’s not at all the conclusion reached by Jim Gordon or the movie. I don’t want to spoil the ending, but that’s not at all how the movie wraps up. It ends with a moment of monumental self-sacrifice, a moment that defines Batman as both the hero Gotham City wants and needs.
This is what happens when you let politics trump your critical faculties. It’s why I hate it when conservatives get self-righteous about the little things in movies (demonizing pollution in Wall*E, excessive cursing in Hancock, etc.)…because then we start sounding like Dana Stevens. And nobody wants that.

4 Comments - add your own
DRF — July 18, 2008 at 5:27 pm
Someone once said that the definition of “zealot” was “someone who cannot look at anything without seeing his or her totem issue as the cause, result or other part of it.”
There are anti-Bush zealots and there are pro-Bush zealots, and they both obscure the truth of the matter.
Sonny Bunch — July 18, 2008 at 8:09 pm
Totally right: this is why I’m typically so hesitant in ascribing political takes to the movies I review. I’d rather you break that down for yourself than have a reviewer tell you how it is. (Of course, I made an exception this week when I blogged about ‘The Dark Knight.’ But it is a striking film, one I haven’t been able to stop thinking about since I saw it on Monday. The politics are part of its…strikingness? Is that a word? It’s been a long week.)
Christian Toto — July 19, 2008 at 11:37 am
I’m waiting for the liberal blowback on “The Dark Knight” … any minute now …
And you’re right about being very careful to ascribe your own political views into your reviews. MOST critics don’t bother with such professionalism, alas.
Philip Marlowe — July 19, 2008 at 10:17 pm
Thank you! Seriously, when I read her review I was all, like, “WTF?!”